Jump to content

1/72 MD500E - Profiline and AZmodel


Recommended Posts

Hi,

I've just started both Profiline and AZmodel new MD500E pointed-nose "powered eggs".

First I've took some pictures of the parts removed from sprues and cleaned up.

By this moment I am not going to comment. But I will add some more comments about fit and accuracy later on.

Fuselage - AZmodel top, Profiline bottom

21.jpg

Horizontal tail - AZmodel left (with PE small stabilizers), Profiline right

06.jpg

Vertical tail - AZmodel left, Profiline right

07.jpg

Tail rotor - AZmodel left, Profiline right

20.jpg

Tail rotor mast and Engine exhaust - AZmodel left, Profiline right

19.jpg

Tall ski - Profiline top, AZmodel bottom

08.jpg

Short ski - Profiline top, AZmodel bottom

09.jpg

More to follow ...

Edited by auhlik
Link to post
Share on other sites

... More photos

Main rotor blade - AZmodel top, Profiline bottom

01.jpg

Main rotor mast - AZmodel left, Profiline right

14.jpg

13.jpg

Main rotor collective control - AZmodel left, Profiline right

10.jpg

Main rotor head cover - AZmodel left, Profiline right

11.jpg

And yet more to follow...

Link to post
Share on other sites

... and some interior parts

Pilot seat - AZmodel left, Profiline right

12.jpg

Crew seats and ceiling - Profiline, Not included in AZmodel

18.jpg

Pilot's controls - AZmodel top, Profiline bottom

15.jpg

Control panel - Front - AZmodel left, Profiline (panel and console)

16.jpg

Control panel - Back - AZmodel left, Profiline (panel front and console side)

17.jpg

Front of Main Bulkhead - AZmodel left, Profiline right

02.jpg

Back of Main Bulkhead - AZmodel left, Profiline right

03.jpg

Fuselage Floor - AZmodel left, Profiline right

04.jpg

Aft Bulkhead - AZmodel left, Profiline right (separate shaft cover)

05.jpg

Well, all for now.

Will post more after some assembly.

Regards

Alexandr

Link to post
Share on other sites

It seems I am going to do a sort of compare build.

The idea comes when I've put cockpits together and find out the one from AZmodel to be WAY shorter than the one from Profiline.

Please excuse the image quality. My camera just decided to totally distort colors - everything pink is Profiline, purple is AZmodel.

AZmodel cockpit assembled

26.jpg

25.jpg

24.jpg

Profiline cockpit assembled

31.jpg

28.jpg

30.jpg

Both cockpits compared

AZmodel in front, Profiline aft

33.jpg

AZmodel on the left, Profiline on the right

32.jpg

30.jpg

Next I will put both cockpits into fuselage.

That's all for know.

S.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Awesome. Can you compare the interior length to the Italeri kit, or no? Any comments on the fit of the interior sub assembly yet? Do you have an initial preference? I have two Profiline kits on the way. Is the AZ something I should get or should I pass?

Looking forward to more progress.

Take care,

Austin

Link to post
Share on other sites
Awesome. Can you compare the interior length to the Italeri kit, or no? Any comments on the fit of the interior sub assembly yet? Do you have an initial preference? I have two Profiline kits on the way. Is the AZ something I should get or should I pass?

Looking forward to more progress.

Take care,

Austin

Austin,

Unfortunately I do not have any Italeri kit so I can not compare physical parts. I just find this thread

http://beguesmaker.blogspot.com/2008/07/co...-6a-cayuse.html

From the photos it seems AZmodel could have some roots in Italeri - but I can not proof, sorry.

My personal preference - well, let me say Profiline - up to now. Clear fuselage, decals, attention to details, modification potential - just to say a few reasons.

But I will see later on during the build...

Regards

Alexandr

Link to post
Share on other sites

Some update

Tails compared.

Profiline is the beige one (the light one) and AZmodel is in grey.

Profiline left, AZmodel right

77.jpg

76.jpg

AZmodel left, Profiline right

75.jpg

Profiline tail

79.jpg

78.jpg

80.jpg

AZmodel tail

67.jpg

72.jpg

70.jpg

... next are main rotors...

Link to post
Share on other sites

... Main rotors

Profiline Main Rotor

44.jpg

43.jpg

34.jpg

AZmodel Main Rotor

45.jpg

46.jpg

35.jpg

Rotors compared, beige is Profiline, grey is AZmodel

37.jpg

It's all for now. Coming next - matting cockpit and fuselage.

Regards

Alexandr

Link to post
Share on other sites
Interesting post. I will follow it closely.

I wonder which kit is better and If both can beat the Italeri one.

I cant understand why AZ models offer two kits in one box... I have one Italeri OH-6, one Hughes 500D, and I need just ONE 500E!

Cya!

Really? Just one? For me, there are always other interesting decal options so including two kits in a box is welcomed. Especially since one tends to mess up something, so one always has a second chance. :-D

@auhlik

are the endplates on the tail of the AZ model Pe-parts?

Thanks

Cheers

Thorsten

Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice post Alexandr! Like your build!

I have bought two Profiline 500E's of which I have almost finished one and have an AZ ready for start. I have built a few Italeri 500's in the past.

Just my 2 cts worth after a fairly quick build: the Italeri 500 beats the Profiline kit hands down.

Most parts on the Profiline 500 are quite oversize and too thick (landing gear, rotor blades, tailrotors, tail and tailfins) and need a lot of sanding down before assembly. The small size of the sprue and the way the parts are connected to the sprue make removing parts from the sprue a hazardous job. There are no positioning pins and overall fit is extrremely poor; stock up on your putty! :coolio:

The transparent parts imho are too thick and I have not been able to achieve an acceptable fit on the doors; mine will be a doorless 500 :) .

Pro's: the kit is reasonably priced and ofcourse the subject is great. The quality of the transparent plastic is good (not too brittle). Panel lining on the transparent parts is nice. Decals and options are off the beaten path and countless. And ofcourse any hero deciding to release new helicopter models different from Apaches, Cobras and Black Hawks deserves my praise!

On another thread I read that Profiline might eventually release the 500 in 1:48 and imho that would be a good idea: I get the impression that the quality of the Profiline moulds is just not perfect enough for detail on such a tiny helicopter in 1:72 and ofcourse a giant like Italeri would beat them on the details.

I will see if I can combine the AZ pointy nose, tailfins with the Italeri fuselage, maybe that would just make the perfect 1:72 500E...

Edited by GeejeeZ
Link to post
Share on other sites

I am sorry for a short silence. I have to focus on too many other things... Later today I will post some updates.

@GeejeeZ: Thanks for the opinion. I've never had an Italeri 500 in hand so I have no chance to check your findings.

What I can do is to compare both Profiline and AZ with the official measurement and see if there are any major differences.

Will post the results as soon as possible.

Please stay tuned for comming days. Both kits will be finished and compared side by side.

Regards

Alexandr

Link to post
Share on other sites
I am sorry for a short silence. I have to focus on too many other things... Later today I will post some updates.

@GeejeeZ: Thanks for the opinion. I've never had an Italeri 500 in hand so I have no chance to check your findings.

What I can do is to compare both Profiline and AZ with the official measurement and see if there are any major differences.

Will post the results as soon as possible.

Please stay tuned for comming days. Both kits will be finished and compared side by side.

Regards

Alexandr

Alexandr,

Thanks for update and taking the time to post these photos. I started cutting plastic last night on my 500E.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Alexandr,

Thanks for update and taking the time to post these photos. I started cutting plastic last night on my 500E.

Tank,

Night is the time to sleep with a nice girl! No time for kits ....... models are only in dreams ..... new AH-1G in 1:72 or AH-56 Cheyenne ! :) ;) :P :rolleyes:

Best regards

Stepan

Link to post
Share on other sites
Tank,

Night is the time to sleep with a nice girl! No time for kits ....... models are only in dreams ..... new AH-1G in 1:72 or AH-56 Cheyenne !

Best regards

Stepan

Stepan,

I am married :P :) ....... so I have lots of time for kits. ;)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guys,

As promised...

Completed AZmodel's 500E.

No comments today. I will post overall comment tomorrow after posting images of the Profiline's model.

Part 1

81.jpg

82.jpg

83.jpg

84.jpg

85.jpg

86.jpg

87.jpg

88.jpg

89.jpg

90.jpg

Edited by auhlik
Link to post
Share on other sites

... and here is Part 2 of completed AZmodel's kit

92.jpg

93.jpg

94.jpg

95.jpg

96.jpg

97.jpg

98.jpg

99.jpg

100.jpg

101.jpg

Tomorrow I will have the Profiline kit finished and will try to give some fair comment to both.

Stay tuned...

Regards

Alexandr

Edited by auhlik
Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...